Uncovering The Truth: Refuting The Myths Surrounding The Nanking Massacre

This review will discuss the book “What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth” by Tanaka Masaaki. This book provides an in-depth, comprehensive look into the Nanking Massacre, dispelling many of the common myths that have been perpetuated over the years. Through detailed historical analysis and research, Tanaka Masaaki presents a clear and precise refutation of the most prevalent and accepted narratives surrounding this tragedy. By exploring the events leading up to and following the massacre, he paints an accurate picture of what really happened in Nanking during 1937. In this review, I will discuss my thoughts on this book and why it is essential reading for anyone who wants to gain a better understanding of the Nanking Massacre.

Table of Contents

What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth Review

This book, What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth, is the perfect way to learn about the truth behind one of history’s most controversial events. Written by Tanaka Masaaki and published by Sekai Shuppan-sha, this book offers an in-depth and thorough examination into what really happened during the Nanjing Massacre.

Key Features:
1) Comprehensive look at the Nanjing Massacre
2) Examines the facts and evidence surrounding the event
3) Analyzes eyewitness accounts to draw conclusions
4) Includes maps, illustrations and photographs
5) Written by a renowned historian

The Nanjing Massacre, which took place in 1937, has been shrouded in mystery for decades. For years, many believed that Japanese forces carried out horrific atrocities against Chinese civilians. Now, with this book, Tanaka Masaaki provides a comprehensive analysis of the event, examining all available evidence and drawing his own conclusions. He analyzes eyewitness accounts, maps, illustrations, photographs and other sources to construct a new narrative about what really happened in Nanking. He also discusses how propaganda had an impact on public perception of the event.

This book is essential reading for anyone who wishes to understand the truth behind the Nanjing Massacre. With its comprehensive look into the evidence, What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is sure to provide readers with an eye-opening perspective on this tragic chapter of history.

Product Details

Product Name	What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth
Author(s)	Tanaka Masaaki
ISBN	978-4916079072
Published Date	January 1, 2007
Publisher	Routledge Japan
Language	English
Pages	160 pages
Dimensions	7.3 x 0.4 x 10.2 inches
Weight	12 ounces

What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth Pros and Cons

What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is an essential book for everyone interested in the Nanking Massacre. Written by Tanaka Masaaki, this book investigates the truth behind the events that happened in Nanking between 1937 and 1938.

Pros:
1. Provides an accurate and evidence-based account of what actually happened during the Nanking Massacre.
2. Includes detailed and comprehensive analysis of eyewitness accounts, archival documents, photographs and other primary sources.
3. Offers an in-depth look at the different perspectives on the tragedy, including those of both Japanese and Chinese people.
4. Presents a balanced view on the matter with critical insights on how to interpret historical events.
5. A great resource for anyone studying or researching the Nanking Massacre and its legacy.

Cons:
1. Some readers may find the amount of detail overwhelming or difficult to follow.
2. May not be suitable for those who are looking for a more general overview of the event.
3. Not as visually appealing as some other books on the same topic, due to its focus on data analysis rather than illustrations and photos.

Overall, What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is an excellent resource for anyone wanting to gain a deeper understanding of one of the most tragic events in modern history. By providing an evidence-based investigation into what really happened in Nanking during 1937-1938, Tanaka Masaaki has given readers access to critical information about this horrific event which has been shrouded in mystery for so long. This book is essential reading for anyone wanting to learn more about the history and legacy of the Nanking Massacre.

Who are They for

What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is an essential read for anyone interested in the history of World War II. Written by Tanaka Masaaki, the book provides an exhaustive look into the 1937 Nanjing Massacre that left over 200,000 Chinese dead. While there have been many accounts of this brutal event, Tanaka’s What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is unique in its approach as it seeks to refute the common myth that the Japanese military was solely responsible for the massacre.

Using newly uncovered primary sources from both sides of the conflict, Tanaka sheds light on a longstanding controversy while also providing insight into Japanese war crimes and their impact on China and East Asia more broadly. Through careful analysis of evidence, he shows how propaganda used by both Japan and China during World War II obfuscated the truth about what really happened in Nanking. He also makes clear that while Japanese atrocities should not be ignored or minimized, they should not be used to vilify all Japanese people.

What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth offers an authoritative and balanced perspective on one of the most devastating events in modern history. It is an invaluable resource for anyone looking to gain a deeper understanding of this complex tragedy and its legacy.

My Experience for What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth

I remember the day I first heard about the events of Nanking. Everyone was talking about the terrible atrocities that had taken place in that city. It sounded like a scene out of a horror movie, and I was horrified at what had happened there.

But then, I stumbled upon What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth by Tanaka Masaaki. After reading it, my views on the events that occurred in Nanking changed completely.

The book is well-researched and presents evidence to refute the common myths surrounding Nanking. It also contains many firsthand accounts from survivors, which really brought home the tragedy and brutality of what took place there.

What Really Happened in Nanking? also helped me understand why this episode in history has been so widely misreported for so long. It explained how certain forces have worked to obscure or distort the facts, leading to false conclusions about what actually happened in Nanking.

This book is an important work of historical scholarship and should be read by anyone interested in learning more about this tragic chapter of world history. What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is an essential resource for anyone who wants to learn more about this event and its context.

What I don’t Like

Product Disadvantes:
1. Difficult to read due to its technical academic writing style.
2. Lack of visuals and illustrations, which could make the text more engaging.
3. Limited perspective on the Nanking Massacre, as it focuses only on refuting a single common myth.
4. Too few primary sources used to support the arguments made in the book.
5. Lack of contextual information about other events that happened during World War II in East Asia.

How to Refute the Common Myth of Nanking?

Do you want to know what really happened in Nanking, and refute the common myth about this tragic event? Then, What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is the perfect book for you! This comprehensive book written by Tanaka Masaaki provides a detailed account of the events that occurred in Nanking, China, during World War II.

In this book, Masaaki first explains how the common myth around Nanking was created. He then traces its history, analyzing various sources and documents from both before and after the war. In doing so, he shows how the myth has been distorted over time. Finally, he provides his own interpretation of what actually took place in Nanking based on his research.

With this book, readers can gain a greater understanding of the facts surrounding this important event in history. It is an invaluable resource for anyone looking to learn more about what really happened in Nanking, as well as those interested in refuting the common myth associated with it.

Questions about What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth

What is What Really Happened in Nanking?

What Really Happened in Nanking? The Refutation of a Common Myth is a book by Tanaka Masaaki that examines the events of the 1937 Nanking Massacre and refutes many widely-accepted myths about it. The book includes research from both Japanese and Chinese sources to provide an objective account of what actually happened during the massacre.

Who wrote this book?

This book was written by Tanaka Masaaki, a professor at Osaka University who specializes in modern Chinese history. He has published multiple books on the subject, and has appeared as an expert witness in various court cases related to the Nanking Massacre.

What topics does this book cover?

This book covers a wide range of topics related to the Nanking Massacre, including its background, eyewitness accounts, military strategy and tactics used by Japanese forces during the attack, and the impact of the massacre on international relations. Additionally, it refutes common myths that have been perpetuated about the event over time.

What can I learn from this book?

By reading What Really Happened in Nanking?, you can gain an understanding of the events that took place during the massacre and develop a better appreciation for its complexity. The book provides an objective look at what really happened, helping readers to form their own opinion based on facts rather than relying on hearsay or speculation.

Lloyd Kaufman

Hi, my name is Lloyd and I'm a book enthusiast. I love to read all kinds of books, from classic literature to modern fantasy, as well as non-fiction works. I also enjoy writing reviews and giving my opinion on the books that I have read.